Sister Sword of Desirable Mindfulness (fiberaddict) wrote,
Sister Sword of Desirable Mindfulness

  • Mood:

Thoughts on Wheels and Spinning

So, I was pointed to a blog entry by Fiberlife called "Making a Spinner" (it's her Nov. 23 entry). It's very well-written, has a lot of good points - the most notable being that the best wheel does Not make the best Spinner.

I agree with that statement....but wanted to put my own thoughts down on why I (and others) go out and spend big bucks on wheels, when perhaps a run-of-the-mill kit wheel can do the same thing.

I started my spinning habit with the ever so poplular Ashford Traveller. It's a nice little wheel, very portable, good for beginners (slow-ish ratios, not a lot of "extras" to confuse you, pretty sturdy, and relatively inexpensive)...But. It's a "modern" wheel.

This doesn't mean anything for those who spin just to spin. At the time I got into weaving/spinning/fiber arts, we were pretty active in the SCA. Now, the local group here has the Elizabethian Gestapo, who enforce the costume (excuse me - "Garb") authentication, but they are pretty lenient on the textile tools side of things. My Ashford fit right in with the Schachts, Lendrums, Ashfords, and (yes!) even a Babe wheel or 2. I was happy with it...until Steve (late DH) decided to get into the SASS (Single Action Shooting Society).

*whew* I only *thought* the SCA was authentic! I think that SASS is an offshoot of the Civil War reenactors - they recreate the American Old West, from...1860-ish to 1900-ish (I think - they may not cover that much time). They STRICTLY enforce (or at least, the group Steve fell in with) the garb and accoutrements of the time period. My little Ashford - not so much allowed.

The group he got involved with had a couple of...for lack of a better term "faire grounds" set up. Think RenFaire, but in an Old West style. Saloons, Boarding Houses, Sutlers, etc. Cool set-ups....and the people were quite nice. The sutlers jumped on me (in street clothes - Steve, of course, was all gussied up) and started pulling out garb for me to look at - I knew I was in over my head when the costume included Undergarments (not just corsets, mind you - but Underwear, stockings, etc. :blink:blink:)

So, Steve and I started discussing things. *g* He wanted me to go, so we could spend time together. I don't like shooting - I can shoot, and I'm good,'s not so much my thing - but I was willing to go along if I could sit on the boardwalk and Do Something while I waited for him to finish playing Cowboy. He agreed that an antique wasn't suitable for this....and told me to start looking around.

Well, my friend had 2 Alden Amos wheels, and had sung their praises to me every chance she got. So, I contacted him - he can, and will, build just about any type/style of wheel you could possibly want. The drawback? They are expensive (my Ashford was $295, my first AA was $1100). BUT - they are built for *you* - the treadle length is set up such that your normal walking speed translates into easy treadling, the wheels are heavy enough that you can start and stop them with a thought, the ratios are set up for the grist of yarn you normally spin...and they're drop dead gorgeous. It didn't take more than 1 picture to put Steve firmly on the AA bandwagon. *eg*

So, anyway, 1 year later I had me a lovely, period-correct, Scottish Castle Wheel. (late 1880's, if I remember correctly). It works for the Scottish Gatherings I do, as well, so I was a very happy camper. A few months later, Alden offered to make me a "jumbo" flyer - since the wheel came hysterically correct, the flyer and bobbins are *small*. That arrived about 6 months later...and I've never looked back.

Now, how does this affect *my* spinning? Well, I can sit at my Ashford for maybe an hour before I have to get up and do something else. (The Ashford Joy I had was a bit worse - I could demo all day on it, but not comfortably, and not efficently. The small drive wheel makes for more treadling - my legs got pretty tired!) It has a 16" drive wheel, and for finer grist yarns, I have to treadle like a madwoman. My Scottish wheel has a 22" drive wheel. I can sit at her for *hours* with no pain, no cramps, no tiredness. I can start her with just a tap of my toe (the Ashford requires a quick push with the "off" hand), she stops on a dime (just stop treadling!), and the takeup is highly responsive. It's to spin on the AA than it is on the Ashford - the Ashford is more like work, the AA is vacation, if that makes sense.

Yarn-wise? I can't really see a difference, in heavier grist yarns (say, common knitting-weights.) Yarn is just that - yarn. I have a lovely skein of true worsted that I spun from some hand-combed Romney on the Ashford - I only know that because I had just finished spinning all the tops when my AA arrived. I haven't spun worsted on the AA yet - I dove back into nice, bouncy woolens - but....when I do, the only difference will be in *my* skill, not the wheel I spun it on.

So, with all that, why did I buy another AA? Because I wanted to replace the Joy wheel with something I would find a real joy to spin on for demos. All the other "travel" wheels out there have the same drawbacks the Joy has - small drive wheel, lots of treadling to put out finer grists......and most of them look modern. *I* don't care, but I've noticed at demos - if the wheel isn't the "traditional" Saxony type, people don't think you're really spinning. (Damn Disney anyway, with their Sleeping Beauty! *eg*) Even with my Castle wheel I still had to explain to people what it was - I had one guy argue with me that it *couldn't* be a spinning wheel, because his Grannie's wheel didn't look like THAT, and hers was REAL. *sigh* My Norwegian has a 24" drivewheel, but has a smaller footprint than my Scottish wheel. I can pick her up with one hand and carry her anywhere I need to put her. Plus, she's "traditional" looking.

The only thing that will make a better spinner, is to actually sit down and Spin. I don't enough time to actually put that into practice right now, but I'm working on it. My 2 AA's will help with that - if you like the tools, you tend to spend more time using them. I found myself looking for excuses NOT to spin on my Joy, which is what finally made me decide to let her go to a home where she'd be used. I don't like spinning on the Traveller, because it's work, but I'll keep it for sentimental reasons (plus, I don't mind loaning it out to folks who want to learn to spin.)

And now, I think I have some spare time this AM to actually put my money where my mouth is - I'm gonna go dig up some wool and spin a bit before work.
Tags: spinning

  • Just FYI

    So, the FDA has approved Pfizer’s Comirnaty vaccine. This is NOT the one currently being administered (that one is Biotech), but it doesn’t matter.…

  • July Update

    I seem to be on a once-a-month update schedule here.......:shrug: Works for me. We got quite a bit done this month - mostly sewing. I have filled…

  • June Recap and Photo catch-up

    Because I've been a busy little Fiberaddict. :lol: I can't remember when I actually sewed up some of these, so I'll just post them. I do remember the…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.